Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Dolan's avatar

Hi Antonia,

Your sustained ability to write with such authenticity just AMAZES me. My lowly Newsletter still struggles for topics and its inability to find such CONSISTENCY is a great effort. I think the disarray in the world that came to be after the violence of 100s of years of realignment in Europe (1800s, WW1, WW2), if run as a computer simulation would lead to WILDLY DIFFERENT results with only small changes in boundary conditions. After lots of history reading, my opinion of the Depression and WW2 was that the WHOLE WORLD chose dictators and regardless of the revisionist historians, America chose a BENEVOLENT leader in FDR. Different leadership for most of the world would have led to wildly different results. That, I believe is the REAL THREAT of the world we live in today.

It is quite easy to be dark and judgmental about what came to be in Russia, FSU and Russia 2.0. While some of it is likely cultural, there is also the result of chance cascading. I think the Korean Peninsula is the strongest validation of the theory of chance. North of the parallel they eat tree bark and live in perpetual darkness. Their relatives 30 miles south live a SciFi life.

Your writing energizes me to learn more about Russia. As far as chance, the FACT that your life bifurcates and ends up in this place and results in this great Newsletter is REASON FOR HOPE.

Expand full comment
Mike Sowden's avatar

I haven't read anything beyond the first paragraph. Because - good grief, that first paragraph.

Good lord.

I'll have a strong cup of tea to steady my nerves, then come back and keep reading.

Good *lord*.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts